I always had query on Kshanik Upadan. For every paryay there is a anantarpurva Kshanik Upadan present by niyam. Hence if we go back infinity…what was the first Kshanik Upadan or how was it created…there is no definite answer I found. MMP says jeeva and karma present in one anothe’s vicinity from eternity but in the context of Kshanik Upadan, how does it work. Can anyone please explain.Thanks for your time.
जहां भी विश्व व्यवस्था को अनादि-अनिधन स्वीकार किया जाएगा, वहां first cause या prime mover का concept लागू नहीं होगा। कारण कि first cause या prime mover को स्वीकार करते ही अनादिनिधन वस्तु व्यवस्था सिद्ध नहीं होती। भिन्न कर्ता करण आदि को भी स्वीकार करना पड़ेगा जिससे अन्य बहुत सारे अनुत्तरित प्रश्न उत्पन्न होंगे।
Even going back to infinity, there isn’t any starting point, hence there isn’t any first Kshanik upadan. Though there is always a Kshanik upadaan for every paryay as it is definitive of process(as it indicates what the prior stage or paryay before the particular paryay is), it is not possible to point out the first cause in the eternal series.
Yes, but it is a niyam that every paryay must have prior anantar purva kshanik upadan. Hence how did the first paryay started?